Will Ashton 26 min read

Closing travel’s creative gap: every trip told differently

Travel’s creative gap: every trip told differently

Travel’s creative gap: every trip told differently

Executive summary

“The algorithms ask the same of every advertiser: give them plenty of distinct ads and let them find the right person for each one. With so many reasons to book, travel should be better placed than anyone. Yet most travel accounts reach the auction with a handful of hero ads, and the variety in the business never makes it into the feed.”

Few considered purchases carry as many emotional pulls as a holiday. Every traveller arrives with their own reason to book: a return to an ancestral home, three generations of a family together for a week, a honeymoon, a solo adventure years in the planning.

Each of those reasons is a different ad, and variety is what ad platforms like Meta and TikTok now reward. Their AI-powered algorithms read each ad to decide who should see it, so the brands that give them more distinct creative to work with win.

With its multitude of motivations, travel should be leading, yet too many brands are stuck on the tarmac while other categories take off. To find out why, we commissioned NewtonX to survey 54 senior travel marketers across the UK, Europe and the US, at airlines such as easyJet and Delta, hotel groups including Hilton and Marriott, and booking sites like Booking.com and Expedia. We followed up with five in-depth interviews and set the findings alongside Nest’s own performance data.

74%
plan to spend more on paid social
15%
feel well set up for where the platforms are heading
76%
hit a ceiling when they try to make more creative
  1. All changeThe first chapter looks at how Meta and TikTok have rebuilt their ad platforms around AI, handing targeting to the algorithm and leaving creative as the main lever marketers control. While 74% of travel marketers plan to spend more on these platforms, only 15% feel well set up for where the platforms are heading.
  2. Too few ads, too few ideasThe ads themselves are thin on the ground. Half of the travel marketers we surveyed run 20 or fewer unique ads, at least 95% fewer than the 443 run by the average Nest ecom client. And the ideas behind them are thinner still. 65% say a new ad changes only the surface, and fewer than one in ten say it brings a new concept.
  3. Travel knows its travellers, but mainly shows them all the same adThe brands we spoke to know their travellers well. One hotel group talks of 37 distinct personas. Getting them into the feed is harder. 94% build creative around traveller types, yet only 39% make each type its own ad. As the hotel group put it: “We don’t have enough content to link to this level of customer persona.”
  4. Runway too shortAsked what most slows their creative getting to market, travel marketers put brand sign-off first (31%), ahead of budget and ROI guardrails (22%) and production capacity (19%). And 76% hit a ceiling when they try to make more creative, though most still plan to spend more. The budget is there, and so are the barriers.Several of the larger businesses we interviewed described a sector slow to change. As one airline loyalty marketer put it: “We are evolving our approach, but it is like trying to handbrake turn a cruise ship.”
  5. AI is widely tried, rarely embeddedAI could answer many of the challenges in this report. 94% use AI somewhere, but only 22% use it systematically, and the biggest barrier is expertise (48%). As one cruise marketer put it, letting a platform create “without a massive amount of human oversight is not going to fly.”
  6. Cleared for take-off: closing the creative gapTaken together, this is an operating-model gap. Travel brands hold the pictures, the personas and growing budgets, but the way they make and approve creative has not caught up. The final chapter sets out how to close it, with a strategy built on the traveller, creative volume and variety by design, and Nest AI Creative to deliver at the pace the platforms reward.

Section 1: All change

“It’s not easy to win on Meta and TikTok, and the reason for that is creative. You need a lot of it, it needs to be varied to match the myriad of interests of the users, and you need to iterate it at speed to keep up with the differing burn rate on the platforms.”

Few sectors are being transformed by AI as much as advertising. Meta and TikTok have rebuilt their ad platforms around AI, investing in the chips, data centres and models that match each person with the right ad at the right time.

Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg calls it nothing short of “a redefinition of the category of advertising” as the platform commands a rising share of ad revenues. As a feed loads, Meta’s Andromeda engine now sifts through tens of millions of ads to choose the single one most likely to land.

The algorithm now reads the ad itself to decide who should see it. The sharper that matching gets, the more the platforms ask of advertisers. The way to win is to give the algorithm more to choose from, and volume and variety are now the main lever on performance, ahead of media budget.

That should suit travel better than most. Few categories have as many reasons to book, and each one gives the algorithm something new to work with. The challenge is strategies haven’t adapted fast enough to meet the accelerating technological change.

-14%
cost per acquisition for Nest ecom clients running two to three times more creative over Black Friday 2025
+38%
revenue for the same brands, on 13% more spend
Closing travel’s creative gap: Nest x Meta, 25th November, 9am, Meta Brock Street

Closing travel’s creative gap before January

Last Black Friday, the Nest ecom clients who went into retail’s peak with two to three times more creative than the year before made 38% more revenue on 13% more spend. Travel’s peak is January, and there is still time to go into it the same way.

In this session, Carys Rush from Meta’s travel team will explain what Meta’s AI wants from your creative.

Then we’ll run the system Nest built to feed it: a distinct ad for every property, season and traveller, each one showing exactly what your customer will book.

Date
25th November, 9am
Venue
Meta Brock Street, London
Hosted by
Nest x Meta
Save your spot

Shifting sands

Travel has another urgent reason to act. AI assistants now answer many of the travel questions that once sent people to search results, and organic referrals to top US travel sites fell 20% year on year in 2025. A majority of marketers we interviewed raised it unprompted.

A senior marketer at an international hotel group described a two-track response, with search and paid social each doing their own job: “We are making a lot of investments in GEO and AI visibility topics, but paid media, we believe strongly, is still going to be a critical part of the upper funnel to bring the traffic in.”

The rising importance of paid social also came through in the survey.

Why the old habits die slowly

74% of the travel marketers we surveyed expect to increase their paid social investment over the next 12 months, 28% significantly, and just 8% expect to cut it. Yet only 15% feel well set up for where the platforms are heading, and the interviewees were candid about why.

Chart: How do you expect your organisation’s paid social investment to change over the next 12 months?
Chart: How well do you feel your current way of running paid social is set up for where the platforms are heading over the next two years (for example Meta, Google, TikTok)?

As one airline loyalty marketer admitted, “we dip our toe in the water and then hope it lasts forever.”

The hotel group was frank: “A hospitality company is not a very tech-driven company… Everything is quite manual right now.” Even a small test “always takes months”. At a luxury cruise line, the brand team still has “a lack of understanding of just how many ads you really need in market”.

The survey bears this out. 20% of travel marketers build their paid social mostly from assets made for brochures, TV or print, and only 17% make their ads natively for social.

The long haul to a booking

The biggest worries for marketers are commercial: turning ads into bookings (56% rank it in their top three), proving return to the business (52%) and measuring performance across a long booking cycle (44%). Meta puts that cycle at around 60 days, longer than standard attribution windows capture. The villa company’s CFO summed up the tension: “Performance is very ROI-driven. Brand is much more long-tail. You do kind of cross your fingers and hope it’s going to work.”

Crossing your fingers gets harder as budgets grow. To see why, we need to start with what travel is actually putting in front of its customers.

Section 2: Too few ads, too few ideas

“We have very few concepts, I would say. It’s really kind of one.”
Integrated marketing lead, luxury cruise line

No sector has better raw material to work with than travel. Private villas with infinity pools, snorkelling off a Caribbean beach, a family trip back to the town a grandfather left behind, the host of experiences that people seek out on passion-driven holidays. Travellers even do much of the sharing for you. More than four in ten (43%) say a viral post or video led them to book a trip or go on an activity, according to TUI Musement.

Yet the ads themselves are thin on the ground. Half of the travel marketers we surveyed run 20 or fewer unique ads, and 75% run 50 or fewer. The average Nest ecom client runs 443. For half the sector, that is at least 95% fewer ads for the algorithm to choose from.

Chart: Approximately how many unique ads do you have running at the moment?

The spice of life

Low volume would matter less if each ad brought something new. Most don’t. 65% say a new ad changes only the surface: the destination, the price, the imagery or the traveller it is aimed at. 26% change the reason to book. Fewer than one in ten say a new ad brings a new concept, ie the reason, the traveller and creative.

Chart: When your organisation puts a new paid social ad live, how does it usually compare with the ads already running?

Asked what they regularly change, marketers put the destination (69%) and the price (65%) at the top, but the reason to book at the very bottom (30%). Yet, the why is both the motivating factor for the traveller and the fuel to feed the algorithm.

A flawed strategy

Travel is experienced in glorious technicolour but advertised in sluggish monochrome. The luxury cruise line runs one main brand video for awareness, and much of its consideration activity uses cut-downs of the same film. When the brand team delivered a winter Caribbean push, it was the ship, some snorkelling and a beach. “I’m not sure I would call that a different concept,” confessed its marketing lead.

A hotel group trading in more than 50 markets changes the copy country by country, but “the more graphical content and the media doesn’t change that much”. Its themes are set at the start of the year, and unless a hotel needs a tactical boost, “we stick to the plan”. The villa company is happy with an aspirational look that “seems to work”, though its CFO notes it “pops up all the time, and it’s the same image: luxury, Aperol spritz around a pool.”

One major UK travel operator was blunter about the sector’s habits: “We’re probably incorrectly thinking that if it’s a digital channel you can get away with poorer creative… and so the creative quality suffers.”

Wearing thin

A thin rotation wears out fast. “Especially nowadays, creative fatigues really quickly,” said the cruise marketer, whose conversion campaigns usually get a single asset “expected to run throughout the campaign”. The airline loyalty marketer says more traditional colleagues fear that too much new creative will tire people out.

For an industry built on crossing borders, its ads travel surprisingly badly. 54% tailor creative for their priority markets only and run generic versions everywhere else. Meta’s own travel guidance describes how a single airline or online travel agency can combine destination, travel type and seasonal hook into hundreds of distinct variants.

“If you give the algorithm just one type of asset, just one angle, the machine doesn’t have a lot to play with. You need to feed it with lots of assets and different angles, because people come to the platform for different reasons.”

The frustrating part is that travel knows exactly who it is selling to. Getting those travellers into the feed is another matter.

Questions to ask yourself
1) How many distinct reasons to book do we have live right now across our ads, and how many ads sit behind each?
Why it matters
Half of travel marketers run 20 or fewer ads, and fewer than one in ten say a new ad brings a new concept. The algorithm needs both volume and variety to find each traveller.
Response
Audit the last 90 days of ads and group them into concepts. Then set targets for concepts live as well as ads live, and track them alongside media metrics.
2) When we brief a new ad, do we just change the place or the promise?
Why it matters
Travel marketers most often change the destination (69%) and the price (65%), and the reason to book least of all (30%).
Response
Brief across all five dimensions (destination, season, booking context, traveller and reason to book), and change the reason to book as often as the destination. With every new ad being a fresh combination of the five, its results show you where to build next.

Section 3: Persona non grata?

“Finding people isn’t the problem. It’s just knowing what their intent and context is, and then serving up the right creative.”
Major UK travel operator.

Every brand we interviewed could name its travellers. The hotel group had 37 of them, using machine learning to group its guests into customer personas, right down to individual hotels.

The airline loyalty business has five, from “luxury loyalists” devoted to premium cabins to younger “spend savvies” who love the brand but shop around, each with 15 to 30 demographics underneath.

The luxury cruise line sells to very different guests. From one paying around $700 per person a night for an entry-level suite, and an ultra-high-net-worth traveller who might spend $150,000 on a single trip in one of its top suites.

The insight is there. The ads to match it are not. 94% of travel marketers say they build creative around distinct traveller types. For 46%, that means mainly the same creative, with the copy or imagery changed for each type. Only 39% make each type its own ad. Asked what they regularly change, fewer than half (48%) vary the traveller it is aimed at.

Chart: Do you build creative around distinct customer personas or traveller types (for example the short-break couple, the family booking around school holidays, the solo traveller), rather than one general approach per destination or product?

One size fits all

The interviews were clear about why. “We don’t have enough content to link to this level of customer persona,” said the hotel group’s marketer. The business has now set up a task force on content generation, because it holds back “any effort for the personalisation that we may have”.

The cruise line has the same problem. Its guests might come for “really amazing dining” or “the wellness on board”, “and right now we just don’t have the creative to support it.” The ads are “not different enough to speak to those different people. Right now, it’s just a one-size-fits-all.”

One major UK travel operator summed up the gap between ambition and delivery: “We’ve all bought into the Kool-Aid of one-to-one personalisation… in practical terms it still feels quite hard to do.”

Passion projects

The prize for getting it right is growing, especially with travellers increasingly planning around what they love doing, creating a potentially vast treasure trove of emotional drivers. According to one study, 43% of Britons choose a destination to match their interests from the start of planning.

The villa company sees the opportunity in its heritage trips. Large US families, 14 or 15 strong, fly to Sicily to find the town a grandfather came from, and pay up to $100K for a week with private yachts and chefs. Its ads have to reach the parents in their 40s and the grandparents who are often paying for it. Two travellers, two different motivations, and two very different ads needed.

“The great thing about persona strategy is it actually does two things. It can get you those short-term sales, but because you’re making people have an emotional response, you’re allowing people to buy into your brand, and you’re making them brand advocates who will see you through the next three-plus years.”

Knowing who those travellers are is the easy part. Making enough ads for each of them, and getting them signed off in time, is where travel hits the wall.

Questions to ask yourself
1) Is there as much variety in our ads as there is in our travellers?
Why it matters
94% build creative around traveller types, but for 46% that mainly means the same creative with different copy or imagery. Only 39% make each type its own ad.
Response
Put the live ads next to the traveller types they are meant for. Where a type only gets a caption change, brief it its own creative, with its own hook, casting and look. Then run it broad and let the platform find the people who see themselves in it.
2) Are our personas shaping what we make each week, or sitting in a strategy deck?
Why it matters
The hotel group can group its guests into personas down to individual hotels, but has “not enough content to link to this level of customer persona”.
Response
Build a small set of personas from booking data, each on a page: the motivation, the barrier, the creative cues and the moment the customer thinks “that’s me”. Map them with the brand team, then name them in every brief and weekly creative meeting.

Section 4: Runway too short: the production and sign-off squeeze

“Brand is the biggest roadblock.”
Integrated marketing lead, luxury cruise line

The last two chapters set out what travel needs to make: more ads, with more ideas behind them, aimed at more of its travellers. Every one of those ads has to be briefed, made and approved before it can run. For most travel brands, that is where the runway runs out.

76% of the marketers we surveyed hit a ceiling when they try to make more creative. 57% can stretch a little before they reach it. Only 24% can scale up easily. Yet 30 of the 41 who hit that ceiling still plan to spend more on paid social.

Chart: When you want to produce more paid social creative than usual, for example ahead of a seasonal peak, what happens?

That capacity issue is only getting more critical, because the wheels of the machines are spinning ever faster, and at different rates. ‘TikTok burns creative twice as fast as Meta,’ Gisela Benini, Nest’s Head of Paid Social, told a recent audience at TikTok, because its audience comes for entertainment and gets through far more content.

Sign-off by committee

So what is slowing travel down? Asked what most holds their creative back from getting to market, Brand sign-off came first (31%), followed by budget and ROI guardrails (22%), production capacity (19%), a lack of usable imagery or footage (15%) and briefing and feedback cycles (9%). Travel is held back at both ends: getting the work made, and getting it approved.

Chart: What is the single biggest thing slowing your paid social creative from getting to market?

At the hotel group, a big campaign takes around eight weeks from idea to approved ad, with “probably more than 16 touch points” along the way. The airline loyalty business runs each new ad through “seven or eight different steps of everyone needing to go in and sign off”, and anything involving its credit card partners goes to a separate legal team as well.

Last-minute boarding

At the luxury cruise line, the problem starts before sign-off. Its creative comes from a brand team in another country and “really needs to have a lot of vetting done”, and the paid social team often gets its toolkit a week before go-live, with no part in the planning behind it. The same brand team makes “a lot of beautiful video for organic social”, but does not want it used in paid.

Travel brands often have more people to please, too. The villa company’s property owners have “quite a lot of power to say, ‘You’re not featuring me enough in your content”. Loyalty schemes answer to their partner brands as well, and every extra voice adds time.

86% do brief seasonal creative at least four weeks before their busiest booking period, and 94% state performance data feeds into the next round of creative. But for 48% it does so slowly, and on platforms where an ad can tire within a fortnight, slow is expensive. The bottleneck is making and approving enough distinct ads in time.

Faster production would help. So would fewer hands on every ad. AI promises both, if travel can work out how to trust it.

.

Questions to ask yourself
1) How many sign-off steps does a new ad pass through, and how much is this delaying us getting ads live?
Why it matters
Brand sign-off is the top single blocker (31%).
Response
Build brand guidelines, tone of voice and what can and cannot be shown into the brief from the outset, so the rules are agreed once and every ad is made against them. Keep a person signing off each ad before it runs.
2) If a winning ad tires in three weeks, can we replace it in two?
Why it matters
Nest typically sees TikTok ads start to fatigue around day 14, yet getting the next informed batch live often takes around 30 days yet 76% of travel marketers hit a ceiling when they try to make more creative.
Response
Move from monthly to weekly production, which turns 12 learning cycles a year into 52. Bank seasonal creative before each booking peak, treating the start of the peak as the production deadline.

Section 5: AI: widely tried, rarely embedded

“There used to be this perception that AI content was bad, and you had phrases like ‘AI slop’. Where we’re moving towards now is that good content is good content, irrespective of how it’s being produced.”
Kris Boger, General Manager, TikTok

On paper, AI answers many of the problems in this report, from too few ads to too little variety. Many travel marketers still doubt the output is good enough for their brand. Those views can date quickly. The tools are improving almost every week, and a judgement made six months ago may no longer hold.

Most have made a start. 94% use AI somewhere in their paid social, but only 22% use it widely and systematically across creative, analysis and optimisation. The rest are at earlier stages: 41% use it in some areas, 31% are still experimenting and 6% have not started.

Chart: How would you describe your current use of AI in your paid social work?

Where it is used, travel has pointed AI at the ads first. 56% use it to make new creative for different traveller types or messages, and 50% to adapt creative for different destinations and markets. Analysing performance and reporting follow, at 48% each. That puts AI to work on the problems in Sections 2 and 3: too few ads, and too many travellers seeing the same one. With only 22% using AI systematically, much of this is likely to be tests and pilots.

Not our ship

The brake is trust. Brand safety and quality control is the most-cited concern (48%), followed by a slow-moving internal culture (41%). For a luxury brand, a near miss is still a miss. The cruise line has tested generic tools and watched the details slip: “it tends to not be our exact ship.” Its marketer was blunt about what that means: “We’re luxury. We need to really control the way that we go to market, and especially allowing a platform to create something without a massive amount of human oversight is not going to fly.”

Perception is part of the problem too. Many of her colleagues come from other luxury brands, and “you say AI and immediately it’s like, okay, wall. Not listening to anything you say.”

Mind the skills gap

Asked directly, travel marketers name people and expertise as the biggest barrier (48%), well ahead of the technology itself (26%) or internal resistance (19%).

Chart: When it comes to getting value from AI in paid social, what is the biggest barrier for your team?

The hotel group shows how the lack of integration is hampering progress. Everyday AI tools are in use in every function, but strategic projects are “quite siloed”, with every department trying to get it done on its own. It is now running RFPs for a generative platform, with a clear aim: “We create once and we can automatically personalise in many countries.”

“The rate of development in AI video generation is unprecedented. It was pretty quick two years ago. Now we’re getting major video releases every week, in many cases twice a week, and these are coming from the biggest names in tech: Google, OpenAI, Alibaba and ByteDance.”

The tools will keep improving whether travel is ready or not. The worry the interviews kept returning to was getting the product wrong, and that is a problem the right rules can solve. With the technology moving this fast, travel marketers need to set those rules now, before the ship has sailed. The final chapter shows how Nest AI Creative can solve the challenges outlined in this report.

Section 6: Cleared for take-off: closing the creative gap

“If I need to double my ad volume, does that mean I need to double my creative headcount? This really isn’t the case. Variety is just as important as volume, because we know creative is the new targeting. So we need lots of ads and lots of ideas.”

Nest’s answer to the creative gap has three parts, working together: a strategy built on the traveller, creative volume and variety by design, and a pace the algorithms reward.

1. Strategy first: start with the traveller

The work begins with a senior strategist who bridges brand goals and performance. Some brands arrive with detailed personas, and the first job is to pressure-test them in a workshop, looking at where they came from and the evidence behind them.

For others, the strategist starts from scratch, turning booking data and customer research into a small set of personas, each with its own reason to book. Either way, the personas belong to the brand, and they only work if the whole business buys into them.

The job is to then translate those personas into a structure for testing: what motivates each traveller, what stops them booking, and where they are in the journey.

Travel adds a second axis: time. The average travel booking cycle runs to around 60 days, and the traveller dreaming in January is in a different mood from the one comparing prices in March. One major UK travel operator already plans around it: “Are you six months, three months out, two days out?” Each stage needs its own creative.

For this to work, the personas have to leave the strategy deck.

According to Maddie O’Reilly, Nest’s Lead Creative Strategist: “If your team aren’t talking about personas by name in your weekly meetings the strategy is not yet ingrained.”

2. Volume and variety by design

The quickest route to more ads is combination. Travel can brief across at least five dimensions: the destination or property, the season and booking calendar, the booking context, the traveller and the reason to book. Each one multiplies the others. One hotel becomes a short-break couple’s escape, a school-holiday family base and a heritage trip for three generations, each with its own ad and its own reason to book.

The content can come from wherever fits: the brand’s own team, creators, shoots, existing assets put to work, and human-guided AI production. Some of it may already be on the shelf. The luxury cruise line’s brand team makes “a lot of beautiful video for organic social” that it would rather keep out of paid.

Each platform needs its own cut. According to Gisela Benini: “What performs on TikTok will perform quite well on Meta, but the opposite is not true.”

3. Delivered at pace

A team producing new creative monthly gets 12 chances a year to learn what works. A team producing weekly gets 52. One airline marketer we surveyed wants to be “faster to gather insights during campaigns rather than waiting until the end.”

Nest runs that weekly cycle with Nest AI Creative, its proprietary AI platform, and Nest’s team reviews everything before a client sees it.

Two habits help. Treat the booking peaks as production deadlines, with creative banks built before the January peak, Easter, summer, October half-term and Christmas, so the algorithm has the most variety when CPMs are highest. And once the creative is deep enough for each traveller and destination, consolidate.

Meta finds its Advantage+ sales campaigns deliver significantly lower CPA than manual structures in travel, yet adoption stays low because teams do not want to give up control of budgets by destination. TikTok’s Smart+ works the same way. Deep creative makes that trade easier to accept.

Inside Nest AI Creative

Nest AI Creative starts with context. Before it makes a single ad, it builds a picture of the brand from its website, guidelines and list of don’ts, so everything it produces starts on-brand.

It then analyses every live ad by traveller type, message and content style, so a brand can see which traveller and which idea is working at each stage of the funnel. It spots what the winning ads have in common and feeds that into the next brief.

It also answers the cruise line’s worry that generic tools “tend to not be our exact ship”. Nest AI Creative can lock a model, product or location in place, so the ship, cabin or view in every ad is the one the customer will book. A variance slider sets how far each new ad strays from the brief, and a proven ad can be localised into versions for each market.

Every ad still goes to the brand team before it runs, and each approval or rejection teaches the system what passes. Sign-off stops being a gate at the end and becomes a set of rules the system learns from.

“With Nest AI Creative, we start off with a layer of context: all of the brand information, so that everything we produce is consistent with the brand guidelines for what to say and not say, what to show and not show. So when we’re creating finished ads, we’re confident that what we’re generating is going to match what the brand teams and the creative teams are going to be approving.”

The platforms will keep asking for more. Few categories have more to give than travel. Feed the algorithms what they need, and your audience will wish they were there, and then book.

Closing travel’s creative gap: Nest x Meta, 25th November, 9am, Meta Brock Street

Closing travel’s creative gap before January

On 25th November at Meta’s London office, Carys Rush from Meta’s travel team will explain what Meta’s AI looks for in travel ads. Then we’ll run the system you’ve just read about: a distinct ad for every property, season and traveller, each showing the real room, ship or view the customer will book.

Date
25th November, 9am
Venue
Meta Brock Street, London
Hosted by
Nest x Meta
Save your spot

The brands pulling ahead made a decision. This is yours.

  • £75k+/month paid media spend
  • Creative fatigue or performance plateau
  • Multiple markets or audiences